Women in State Hospitals: Elizabeth Griffitts
Women play an interesting if subdued role in the history of the insane asylum. When researching the mentally ill of the 1900s, one may be met with the faces of women who were deemed “incurably insane,” whereas stories of men are more sparse. Similar to Susie Harrell, a woman by the name of Elizabeth Griffitts was thought to be unwell and taken to an insane asylum. The difference in Elizabeth Griffitts history, however, is that it has been researched and uncovered by modern relatives.
Elizabeth Griffitts’ story is one that had been kept a family secret for a couple of generations before her granddaughters wanted to learn more about this almost hidden familial figure.1 Elizabeth, a Northern Irish Catholic, married a Doctor from Tennessee, and she moved with him to various places in the American South.2 Elizabeth and her family moved to Alabama, and this transition would prove difficult for her.3 Elizabeth is described by her husband as falling into a bout of depression and anger, and these outbursts of discontent with living in Alabama led to her husband accusing her of being insane.4
Elizabeth denied this accusation, but unfortunately, being an unconventional and eccentric woman convinced of her sanity was enough of a diagnosis for the physicians of Bryce Hospital.5 Elizabeth’s husband admits in an interview to the physicians at Bryce Hospital that she could be described as peculiar, eccentric, and strong-minded, and he firmly argued that she was insane.6 Elizabeth’s attempts at proving her lucidity only furthered belief in her lunacy as the physicians deemed her incurably insane on the grounds that she was delusional, paranoid, and “lacking insight into her own condition;” therefore trapping Elizabeth in a paradox of either admitting insanity in an attempt to prove she was lucid or continue to deny these accusations.7 Her condition was further described as insanity as the physicians noted that Elizabeth was portraying symptoms of a mental illness that led her to believe she was not being treated fairly.8 Her fervent denial and fight against her diagnoses only solidified the physicians’ opinions. Correspondence between Elizabeth and her children and family was banned by her husband, and she died in the hospital after thirty years of admittance, struggling with the brutal consequences of overcrowding and neglect.9 She experienced significant fluctuations in weight, an eye infection that resulted in its removal, and the loss of all but five of her teeth before dying alone without any personal possessions.10
Elizabeth’s story may be an extreme example of what could happen to a peculiar woman of this era, but it is telling how emphatically the physicians were convinced of her insanity. Elizabeth is not the only woman to have experienced these vague diagnoses of paranoia and delusion. A woman called Mrs. H was reported to have a similar diagnosis of “delusions of persecution” while admitted in both Willard State Hospital and the Kings Park State Hospital.11 It appears that women, or perhaps anyone, who expressed discontent inside these institutions would be ignored on the basis that they were insane. Elizabeth is a figure that represents the potential fates of women who were considered unconventional or were considered emotional, and her general treatment in Bryce Hospital depicts the reality that many patients, regardless of gender, faced in the overcrowded walls of the early 1900s American Asylums.
-
Lindsay Byron, “Rewriting Elizabeth: A Life Lost (and Found) in the Annals of Bryce Mental Hospital,” Southern Culture 20.2 (2014): 6.↩
-
Byron, 11.↩
-
Byron, 11.↩
-
Byron, 14.↩
-
Byron, 14.↩
-
Byron, 15.↩
-
Byron, 12.↩
-
Byron, 18.↩
-
Byron, 13.↩
-
Byron, 23.↩
-
David Rothman, Conscience and Convenience, (New York, NY: Taylor & Francis Group, 2002): 357.↩

