Rise in Insane Asylums
Insane asylums began in America in the 1800s and grew with urbanization and an increasing population.1 Prior to the widespread development of insane asylums, the mentally insane were often confined in prisons with other social deviants before mental illness was considered a treatable and curable disease.2 During the mid-late 1800s, there would be a shift in perception of mental illness, theorizing that it could be cured through moral treatment.3 This new form of management saw insanity as a potentially curable condition through physician-led treatment of mentally ill patients.4 Such treatments would include hydrotherapy or packing, depending on the behaviors of the patient.5 Despite this idea of a cure for acute insanity, many insane asylums saw patients that would be there for several years, once again shifting the perception of mental health care later on.6
While having seemingly hospitable roots, the rise in insane asylums can be linked to the need to house social deviants and burdens and the later consequence of overcrowding. The working class of the late 1800s to early 1900s did not have the luxury of being able to afford to personally look after their sick loved ones; therefore, asylums were a viable option for the lower class to send their ill to be cared for.7 This undesired population often included the elderly and incapacitated,8 and other common patients included alcoholics, schizophrenics, and syphilitics.9 Many of these illnesses that were often seen among admitted patients were considered “incurable,” which is contradictory to the original goal of these state hospitals to treat and therefore cure their patients.10 The continuous admittance of “incurable” mental illnesses made overcrowding an inevitable fate. State hospitals became overcrowded in the early 1900s, and the physician-to-patient ratio was around 1:250 between the years 1900-1940.11 One account of an old employee of the Georgia State Sanitarium argued in a newspaper article from 1921 that, in his opinion, around twenty percent likely should not be in admitted in the sanitarium as they are harmless, and he further argued that releasing them would likely save the hospital thousands of dollars.12 Due to overcapacity, it became nearly impossible for physicians to properly treat their patients.13
Because these state hospitals were well over capacity, it became common for patients to be mistreated by the hospital staff.14 Life in state sanitariums was not a rewarding job for the staff. Working conditions were often dismal with long hours, low wages, repetitive schedules, and little time for recreation.15 These unsatisfactory conditions of the nurses and guardians created discontent and resulted in high turnover rates for staff at these state hospitals.16 Because many people saw their time working in insane asylums as temporary, they took out their frustrations on the patients, sometimes resulting in violence.17 Willard State Hospital records many instances of rib fractures among patients as well as arm fractures18 and even an account of a patient dying during an altercation with two attendants.19
-
Andrew T. Scull, “Madness and Segregative Control: The Rise of the Insane Asylum,” Social Problems 24.3 (Feb 1977): 348.↩
-
Scull, 348.↩
-
Rothman, 349.↩
-
Rothman, 349.↩
-
Rothman, 353.↩
-
James Barnwell Heyward, “An Open Letter,” The Bartow Tribune, September 22, 1921.↩
-
Rothman, 352.↩
-
Rothman, 357.↩
-
Rothman, 355.↩
-
Rothman, 357.↩
-
Rothman, 357.↩
-
Rothman, 358.↩
-
Rothman, 359.↩
The focus of insane asylums shifted with the turn of the century, moving to a preventative approach rather than treatment.20 The rise in what would be known as “mental hygiene” coincided with the expansion of state hospitals,21 spreading their staff thin, and the introduction of new, and sometimes dangerous, treatments for mental illnesses.22 People tried to resolve the extreme overcrowding that was being seen in hospitals all over America through various alternatives, such as family and outpatient care; however, these programs did not gain any form of success for quite some time.23 State hospitals were unwilling to extend their funds to off-site facilities and send away their most valued patients: patients who were able to work.24





