Methodism during the Late Nineteenth Century, 1870-1900

Georgia Methodists in the late nineteenth century experienced the impact of reconstruction, and the increasing racial tension that started decades before. For many, Georgians the reconstruction was the time of expansion and making a new identity for themselves. These physical and societal changes of the reconstruction spilled into Methodism. Hence this brought African Americans, and women into a more active role in Methodism. In the early part of the century, within Methodism, many different conferences were split on how to deal with their African American congregation. The issue was controversial within the American Churches, especially Southern Church members since slavery was integrated into Southern society. To fit into the Southern narrative, instead of seeing black members of equal status, they believed they need to save the souls of their non-white counterparts. However, after the civil war, northern Methodism conferences and Colored conferences created churches for black citizens even though many black churches were already established under the white Methodism ideology. Under the white Methodism ideology, black churches created various public amenities, including circulating libraries, and athletic and social clubs (1 ). This racial tension grew when many black churches advocated against segregation, by the 1890s (2 ). As groups tried to create “improved” Methodism, the holiness movement expanded in the name of teaching the “perfection teachings”. While race relations increased in tension, there was a change in the roles of gender. Evangelicalism in the south required certain roles for both sexes. The nineteenth masculine culture witnessed a change of ideals from the Old South. There was a culture clash between the dominant aggressive masculine culture and the feminized movement. The clash occurred with denominations, such as Methodism and Baptism condemned the southern male ideals to be “rough and tumble men” (3 ). As the male norms changed so did women. The roles of women and class were a debated topic and caused the distancing of the Methodist sectors, especially concerning the Holiness movement.

Holiness Movement

The Holiness Movement began out of a split from Methodism to teach the original teachings of John Wesley. The holiness did not gain much traction until after the Civil War. The Civil War not only split the regions but also split the Northern and Southern Methodist Church. The low morale after the civil war caused Methodist leaders to call for a holiness revival. The holiness revival was supposed to reconnect believers because they believed that “holiness people are not measuring up…glorious opportunity” proclaimed by Soloman Benjamin during a holiness assembly (4 ). This prayer was nowhere stronger than Georgia. The holiness revival occurred throughout Georgia, starting in towns, and sweeping into cities. The popularity allowed the revival to accompany apart of the Methodist Episcopal Church. To keep this upward swing, a promotion was organized with the northern Methodists. With popularity, continuing holiness leaders, such as William Asbury Dodge of Atlanta created a newspaper with other leaders, called The Way of Life. Along with the Holiness newspaper, upper-class holiness professionals came together to create the Georgia Holiness Association and sign the 1883 Charter. The overall makeup of the charter was diverse even though the majority of the population of Georgia was rural farmers. Even though the Holiness movement was growing in north Georgia, the Methodist Conference became distant. This was due to the fear of the close association between the revival and the Northern Methodists. The Methodist evangelicals feared that the northern elites were taking advantage of the poverty in Georgia. In the Christian Witness, George Watson proclaimed the holiness preachers were like sheep being led to “the shearing” 5 . Even though not everyone agreed with Watson, the Holiness revival continued to be the topic of debate within the Methodism sector. This continued into the early 20th century because of the slight differences in social ideals.

Lastly, the class hierarchy was another important societal sector of nineteenth-century Methodism. The class hierarchy was an important part of Methodism because it was deemed for the poor. This identity can be physically represented in the churches. In an illustration by George W. Roberts of the Stone Methodist Chapel, the churches were often wood and did not have accents, like the Anglican Churches (6 ). Methodism was a denomination for the less fortunate and they believed the decoration of wealthier churches would hinder their salvation (7 ). Methodism welcomed African Americans with a belief in saving them. The population of African American congregations caused a political issue as social norms did agree with Methodism. Unlike, other evangelical churches, Methodist churches advocated against pew ranking, so African Americans could practically sit anywhere. However, as racism increased throughout the country, northern and southern black Methodists created their own churches. Methodism was no longer separated by northern and southern but also by race and culture. The Methodist church of black and white origin showed the division of race and gender but not class. In Methodism, white men of any class could sit on the same pew. This stopped at white men as black men and women were deemed inferior in the religious culture created by the southern society.

  1. Evelyn Brooks, Higginbotham, “Righteous Discontent”: The Women’s Movement in the Black Baptist Church, 1880-1920, Harvard University Press (Cambridge, MA), 2011.↩

  2. Daniel, W. Harrison. The Mississippi Quarterly 52, no. 1 (1998): 180–83. http://www.jstor.org/stable/26477158.↩

  3. David T. Moon, “Southern Baptists and Southern Men: Evangelical Perceptions of Manhood in Nineteenth-Century Georgia,” The Journal of Southern History 81, no. 3 (2015): 563–606.↩

  4. Solomon Benjamin, Echoes of the General Holiness Assembly, (General Holiness Assembly, Chicago, Ill.), 1901,8.↩

  5. Watson, “He Opened Not His Mouth, “Christian Witness (1886), 4, quoted in Briane Turley, “A Wheel Within a Wheel: Southern Methodism and the Georgia Holiness Association, The Georgia Historical Quarterly, Vol. 75, No. 2, (1991), 295-320.↩

  6. Department of Commerce. Bureau of Public Roads. 8/20/1949-4/1/1967. Stone Chapel. 1896-01-01/1963-12-31. Retrieved from the Digital Public Library of America, http://catalog.archives.gov/id/135802963.↩

  7. Christopher H. Owen, “By Design: The Social Meaning of Methodist Church Architecture in Nineteenth- Century Georgia, “The Georgia Historical Quarterly, vol. 75, no.2, (1991): 229.↩

Methodism during the Late Nineteenth Century, 1870-1900