Taboo's, Shell Shock, and PTSD

Why Was Mental Health A Taboo?

There were various reasons as to why mental health affecting the military personnel was not talked about. An origin of this can be linked to how most of the people serving on the front lines were men, and men were placed into this masculine sphere where they could not be 'weak' or 'vulnerable'. From a paper by the Costs of War Project:

“Further, the dominant masculine identity that pervades the military is one that overwhelmingly favors machismo and toughness. Asking for help during trauma or suicidal ideation, then, is necessarily at odds with military culture; ‘acknowledging mental illness is likely to be viewed as a sign of weakness and a potential threat to their careers.’1 "2 

The harsh reality was that these men did have mental issues; however, they were forced into silence because it was seen as something that a man should not have. Most of the mental illnesses at this time were overlooked because of this exact reason; the men within the military were supposed to be these strong and unbreakable people, so these illnesses broke the mirage for civilians learning about war.

  1. Mittal, D., et al., (2013). Stigma Associated
    with PTSD: Perceptions of Treatment Seeking Combat Veterans. Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal, 36(2), 87.↩

  2. Thomas Howard Suitt III, "High Suicide Rates among United States Service Members and Veterans of the Post 9/11 Wars" (Rhode Island: Brown University, 2021), 21.↩

Shell Shock

During WWII, the term shell shock was most commonly used to describe the effect war had on military members before Post-Traumatic stress disorder was coined. This illness first occurred during world war one and was entirely new to the military psychiatrists of the time3. The affected men would leave “... the trenches stuttering, crying, trembling and at times were even paralysed and blind”4. Military personnel affected with shell shock would have been completely affected at all times and had extreme physiological reactions; however, those affected were accused of faking it and would be harshly disciplined.. It was deemed ‘shell shock’ because of the affected persons proximity to explosions5. Moving into WWII, these military psychiatrists significantly developed American psychiatry, and they introduced many new diagnoses and treatments6 .

  1. Hans Pols, “Waking up to Shell Shock: Psychiatry in the US Military during World War II.” (Endeavour 30 no. 4, 2006), 144↩

  2. Ibid.↩

  3. Ibid.↩

  4. Ibid.↩

Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder

The more modern and accurate term used for shell shock is post traumatic stress disorder. PTSD has been more separated from shell shock as it has more specific symptoms. A good resource to learn more is the PTSD Checklist provided by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, and these are still some of the symptoms that were addressed when diagnosing shell shock. A large separation between these two is the role that sleep plays. PTSD has a direct link to traumatic events and combat trauma; there is such a connection to a person's physiological reaction that PTSD heavily affects sleep7. There is also how “... nightmares are a specificity of this disorder”8 which determines its severity; roughly 67-69% of veterans are affected by this type of disorder9

  1. Emeric Saguin, et al. “Sleep and PTSD in the Military Forces: A Reciprocal Relationship and a Psychiatric Approach,” in Brain Sciences 11 (1310: 2021), 1 ↩

  2. Ibid, 5.↩

  3. Ibid, 7.↩

Taboo's, Shell Shock, and PTSD